Which one should I choose between the FTX-1F and the IC-705?

BA8BAK

上周拿到B类操作证了，虽然手里早就有DX10了，但是只带出去让C佬用了几次，我全程站后面看没摸过机。但是还是感觉到太重了，带出去太麻烦。看到友台手里的ic-705 瞬间觉得手里的DX10不香了。有点想垫一个呀。。计划是年底12月左右入手，直接上全国不固定。

正在学习CW，后续应该以CW为主，SSB辅， UV段纯粹是为了解决手里只有一个K6手台，无法通联到本地较远的友台的问题

问了AI，推荐我选FTX-1F，性能和续航啥的都比705好，目前它GET到我的点是它能HF和UV段双守

关于操作菜单的问题，705确实要完胜八重洲的，705进入菜单分类明确，条理清楚，八重洲进菜单直接就是一坨(根据我的DX10得出)

BG2EFX

All of them
I am using PA and ATU at home, with frequency 705.
The FTX-1 I bought was the 100W version, intended for use in a car as a portable power source.
Each has its own advantages.

The FTX-1 can be quickly converted into a hundred-watt unit, but the ugly face of Yaesu selling accessories is truly disgusting.
705 remains classic in both operation and UI, feeling superior to what a dentist might offer.

FengziLeo

I don't know about the others, but I think battery life isn't a concern. Since I can connect an external power bank, the small amount of electricity from the radio is not enough to do anything.

IL-1

I have two of them, and I've used both. Currently, I recommend the IC705. The X1 is not mature enough; its circuit design needs to be modified. Double-handed operation is better than double-guarding.

IL-1

X1电池虽然大，但是耗电也大，电老虎，实际续航是要打个问号的。性能确实要优于705，但总体待机发热量大，我觉得比较致命，发射几分钟就要温度保护了，我觉得这跟他的电路设计和外观设计有关，705的热控制就很好。X1要使用的话得把背部电池卸下来散热，他的电池正好把散热片给遮住了，积热严重。。。再就菜单方面而言，我觉得比DX10设计的还要差。bug和死机，少蓝牙wifi gps感觉都是小问题了

BA8BAK

IL-1 Thank you for sharing your firsthand experience with another station. It seems that recommending the 705 model isn't without reason.

IL-1

BA8BAK I understand you're planning to use the CW mode primarily, and the Yaesu 705 would be a good choice. The FTX-1 has its strengths in voice communication, and the "super-dx" feature it promotes is indeed quite effective for that purpose. It also offers more UV functionality than the 705, but I'm concerned about its stability, especially regarding temperature control, which I find to be a critical issue. Since Yaesu's DX-10 and later products have been known to suffer from overheating and tube failure, it's important to keep an eye on this aspect.

IL-1

BA8BAK The FTX1 receiver's main performance advantage is its high dynamic range, but it doesn't significantly outperform the DX705. If you really want high performance, you should still consider a mixed receiver like the base station DX10.

BA8BAK

IL-1 Thank you, [Friend's Channel], for sharing your experience so thoroughly. I've already decided to go with the FTX1, but I'll keep an eye out for a good deal on the 705.😁

Or perhaps we can see if there are any new products released in the second half of the year.

DF4_9460

I'm using the Yaesu 705, and I also played with other people's X1Fs at last year's annual meeting. The operation logic of Yaesu is not intuitive.😂 I think the 705 is better. It can be powered entirely by a power bank and a 15V coax cable, and it has built-in GPS, WLAN, and Bluetooth for one-step setup. Furthermore, it has a large inventory, making it easy to obtain technical support.😆

BG6HFD

BA8BAK I've also been looking at small SDR receivers recently. I have a DX10 and a G90s, and I was planning to use the 705 for expanding my UV coverage. However, I saw a video on Bilibili that said the 705 doesn't perform as well as the K6, so I'm not sure what to make of it.🧐

IL-1

BG6HFD It's definitely not as good as a dedicated FM receiver. If you want to work with UV frequencies, you need a specialized device. The 705, which covers the entire band, can be used, but it's not particularly impressive.

BA8BAK

IL-1 The UV performance of the 705 was actually worse than that of the K6, which I didn't expect at all. It really challenged my previous understanding.

BI7CWS

Only need to buy 705, don't worry about the battery, and by the way, the BP272 for only 30 yuan from some online store is really great. You can also solve the problem with a power bank + lure line.
Additionally, that anti-human menu made me a fan of the dental clinic.😂

IL-1

BA8BAK Each field has its own expertise. The UV function of the 705, a full-spectrum portable unit, is essentially a bonus; the small machine can't accommodate too many components, and this statement simply means it can be used, not that it's particularly good.😄Having two guards isn't as good as having two aircraft; both UV and HF are quite effective.

BD3QID

BA8BAK k6信纳比应该比较低

Moonlight

In fact, if you're already familiar with DX10, you can directly check out FTX-1. Otherwise, you'll have to learn the operation logic of two different brands...

BH9DFB_AI6YY

The 705 MHz band is also very strong. Previously, when I used a VHF handheld radio (VHF Hunter 705) with a car antenna, the signal amplification was already S5, but even with a Yagi antenna (specifically, an eight-element Yagi), I couldn't receive anything. Once I connected a Raspberry Pi APRS device, I could receive everything. It's also great to use SSB for satellite communication.

I can't comment on the FTX1 because I don't have one, but the 705 is really great and very playable.

BH4GDU

"Regarding the operation menu, the 705 definitely outperforms the Yaesu. The 705's menu is clearly organized and easy to navigate, while the Yaesu's menu is just a mess (as observed from my DX10)."

That's true.

Moonlight

As for the menu, I actually didn't find it particularly difficult. Both options work fine once you get used to them, and many of the settings can be set once and then never touched again…
I don't think there's really any point in spending more money on the menu just to save a little.
Take a look at the features and specific prices of these two machines, and then purchase the one that best meets your needs.
**Additionally, if you purchase an FTX-1 with a seat, and it meets your needs, you could sell your DX10, so that when you take it out, it's a portable base station, and when you bring it home, it's a stationary base station.**
The FTX-1 is not ideal for competitive gaming due to power consumption concerns, making its performance slightly weaker than the DX10. The DX10 is a better option for competitive use if you have that need; it's best not to sell your DX10 if you require it for competition.

BA8BAK

Moonlight 没考虑过出掉DX10，只想过带DX10去野架

BH3XZT

705 is fine; I find all the operations to be quite comfortable.

闽ICP备2021006864号-7

闽公网安备35020602002794号互联网举报中心

用户协议隐私政策社区规范积分规则中继规则转载须知
更新日志联系我们常见问题友情链接运营报告赞助

浩奇科技（厦门）有限公司

是无线电，把我们联系在一起